Skip to the video
KMAU

What Is Cold Email? How I Made $4,000,000 by Emailing People on the Internet

A note for tomorrow

Get the next one.

Enter your email below to open Kyle Mau's daily email tips with business and career advice.

Cold email is buying hundreds of inboxes and sending thousands a day to a targeted email list of people who you want to sell stuff to. About one in every thousand people is interested. That is the cold email meaning: you are emailing complete strangers, at volume, on a targeted list of people you want to sell something to.

Over the last five years, I’ve made over $4 million from sending emails to strangers via cold email.

All of this started on February 24th, 2022.

Half of that $4 million came from referrals, not from sending a high volume of cold emails themselves.

What Is Cold Email?

What is a cold email? You are emailing complete strangers. You buy hundreds of inboxes, you build a targeted list of people you want to sell stuff to, and you send thousands of those emails a day.

That is the cold email meaning. One in every thousand people is interested.

Do Cold Emails Work?

Absolutely.

Over the last five years, I’ve made over $4 million from cold email. Half of that $4 million came from referrals, not from sending a high volume of cold emails themselves.

I emailed one client. He had a company, I think about 70, 75 people, and they are still clients to this day.

He was in this penthouse with these huge panoramic glass windows, overlooking an ocean, and I felt completely out of my element. I hadn’t been doing sales for a long time. My previous partner had been in charge of lead gen and sales.

I ended up closing that deal. Very small amount of money to kick off, $500.

That company is an e-commerce brand. They’re still with us today. They’ve got, I think, seven or so, maybe ten people working with us.

That one cold email prospect has probably referred somewhere around 15 to 20 people. Real referrals, like putting me in a WhatsApp chat with another business owner and saying, hey, Kyle can help you hire who you need for your business.

It doesn’t really get much better than that.

Another prospect was Andy at Creatively Disruptive, a marketing agency in Arizona. They save about $150K a year hiring through us.

I don’t know how many people they’ve hired exactly through the years. It’s probably close to 15 at this point overall. They’ve probably put me in an email chain with 20 other business owners over the last four years and said, Kyle can help you.

The lesson is that the word of mouth came from the quality and the right fit. It wasn’t just spamming the emails. It wasn’t just getting someone in and getting them to pay us money.

It was finding what mattered to them at the time in those hires, and then delivering on what we actually promised, which four years ago was Ukrainian talent.

How I Made $4,000,000 With Cold Email

Let’s go back to February 24th, 2022. I’m in my apartment in Kyiv, Ukraine. I wake up and there is a bunch of air raid sirens going off.

My wife is physically shaking me awake. I’m thinking at first, yo, what the heck are you talking about? Then I hear the sirens, and I realized that Russia was here.

We spent multiple days camping out in the cold, trying to get out of the border, driving out of Ukraine at like 4:00 in the morning, passing tanks on the road, going like 100 miles an hour through the city.

Then we went to California, where I am from, where my family is from. I moved in at 30 years old with my parents, because we had no idea where we wanted to go or what we wanted to do, and we had a child on the way.

And my mom, three weeks after we got there, she was diagnosed with stage four cancer. She was given a very slim probability of making it through the end of 2022.

At that point I decided, life is way too damn short to be in a relationship, in this case a business partnership, that I was unhappy with. So I split off from the partner and renamed the company from ExecVA to HireUA.

People wanted to help. People wanted to support. That shaped the positioning in the cold emails I started sending.

It was obviously horrific what happened, and I also realized I basically lost everything. I had an apartment I had bought in Ukraine, all my belongings, our entire life that we had spent the last four years building up there. I had lost all of it because of this war.

I kind of realized, well, I made it. Might as well make some of it back. Frankly, at the time I needed to make some of it back to actually support my family.

I spent nearly $10,000 to learn cold email, setting up the inboxes, and I started emailing complete strangers.

How to Write a Cold Email

If you want to know how to write a cold email, I would put the ask in the first line. I would try to keep it to no more than two or three sentences across two lines, and it should get to the point.

People should be able to skip it and understand exactly what you want. I really don’t think there’s any point in doing anything but just getting right to it.

You’re there to sell. They know you’re there to sell because you’re emailing them out of the blue.

There’s really no point in beating around the bush. I think it’s by far the most effective thing.

So before your next campaign, answer the five questions.

What The Hell Does This Industry Actually Care About Right Now?

The message in your cold emails has to connect with what the prospects already believe and what they already give a shit about.

We work with a lot of e-commerce brands. They’re thinking in terms of ads, creatives, building new creatives. They got to test lots of new ones now with AI.

Why Would They Care Today?

What turned those replies into the millions was the next question. Why the hell would they actually care today?

What Deadlines Or Cycles Affect Them?

When should you actually be sending cold emails? Ask yourself: what deadlines or what cycles affect the prospects you’re trying to reach out to.

In quarter four, we work with a lot of e-commerce brands. Black Friday, Cyber Monday is coming up.

So I will ask questions like, I know Q4 is crazy for you. Do you have any roles that you’re looking to fill now, or better to circle back after the holidays or a few weeks after Black Friday, Cyber Monday?

I might say something like, I hope you had a good BFCM.

When you understand the buying cycle of your client and the calendar and all the other crap that goes around their world, you start to create a lot more relevancy in the messaging that you use.

What Words Do They Use?

I use the same language that a direct to consumer e-commerce brand would actually understand. They talk in terms of ROAS. They talk in terms of conversion.

I at one point had an olive oil company, Selo Olive, a DTC e-commerce brand. It was my second business. Most of our sales were during the holidays.

I know how they’re thinking from that, and from working with so many e-commerce brands over the years.

If I just hire a generic cold email agency off the street, they wouldn’t have all these years of accumulated lessons that HireUA has built as we’ve worked with more and more brands. So now you’re speaking their language.

What Happens When The Message Goes Stale?

Here’s the thing that’s going to kill the majority of cold email campaigns: the same language that worked in 2022 with Ukraine.

We’ve now placed from over 40 countries. We do a lot of Eastern Europe, Latin America, the Philippines.

So all that messaging about Ukraine changed over time because markets evolve and clients get more sophisticated. The market will never stop changing.

You got to keep adapting. You have to iterate, try new things. Understanding the people, what they care about, what they’re going through, is what actually makes the money.

What Is a Good Subject Line for a Cold Email?

The best cold email subject line I ever ran was “quack question,” and it was intentional.

I just honestly thought it would be funny, and I tested it thinking it would actually work. It actually got so many replies.

It just gets people to reply, which opens the door.

At the end of the day, who’s googling whether this is legal or not? At the end of the day, you have got to do it. You got to do it for your business, right?

It is completely legal.

It’s not okay, in my opinion, to spam people. If someone has to be removed, you should remove them, and you should do the right thing and try to just generally find targeted people who are likely to be interested.

Yes, everyone’s tired of email, but at the same time, I think the thing that irks me, and this would just be my personal opinion, is that everybody gets this data from LinkedIn.

Apollo, I don’t know for sure, but it looks to me like a lot of these databases are getting it from there. Everyone’s getting it from there.

To me, if the biggest database out there can’t keep the data private, I wonder all the time: why am I on all these lists? How do people get my info?

It’s someone selling it. They’re getting it from somewhere.

I think that the company should be blamed, not the users who choose to do it.

Frequently Asked Questions

What Is Cold Email?

Cold email is buying hundreds of inboxes and sending thousands a day to a targeted email list of people who you want to sell stuff to. You are emailing complete strangers. About one in every thousand people is interested.

Do Cold Emails Work?

Absolutely. Over the last five years, I’ve made over $4 million from cold email, and half of that $4 million came from referrals, not from sending a high volume of cold emails themselves. The word of mouth came from the quality and the right fit, not from just spamming the emails.

How Long Should a Cold Email Be?

I would keep it to no more than two or three sentences across two lines. Put the ask in the first line, get to the point, and write it so people can skip it and still understand exactly what you want. You’re there to sell, they know you’re there to sell, and there’s no point in beating around the bush.

What Is a Good Subject Line for a Cold Email?

The best cold email subject line I ever ran was “quack question,” and it was intentional. I thought it would be funny, I tested it, and it got so many replies. It just gets people to reply, which opens the door.

How Do You Keep Cold Email From Going Stale?

The same language that worked in 2022 with Ukraine did not keep working. We’ve now placed from over 40 countries, and we do a lot of Eastern Europe, Latin America, and the Philippines, so that messaging had to change as markets evolved and clients got more sophisticated. You got to keep adapting, iterate, and try new things.

When Should You Send Cold Emails?

Ask yourself what deadlines or cycles affect the prospects you’re trying to reach out to. For the e-commerce brands we work with in quarter four, I might ask if they have roles to fill now, or if it’s better to circle back after the holidays or a few weeks after Black Friday, Cyber Monday. When you understand their buying cycle and their calendar, you start to create a lot more relevancy in the message.

Is Cold Email Legal?

It is completely legal. It’s not okay, in my opinion, to spam people. If someone has to be removed, you should remove them, and you should do the right thing and try to just generally find targeted people who are likely to be interested.

So before your next campaign, answer the five questions.

  • What the hell does this industry actually care about right now?
  • Why would they care today?
  • What deadlines or cycles affect them?
  • What words do they use?
  • What happens when the message goes stale?

How are you going to iterate. How are you going to adapt. How are you going to survive.